Some Dificult Questions for Freemasonry
Some FAQs about Freemasonry.
A |
---|
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:27 PM)Are there women Freemasons? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: Yes. Women Freemasons have two separate Grand Lodges in the UK.
These bodies follow the same structure as their male counterparts, but
admit only women. The Honourable Fraternity of Ancient Freemasons has lodges in England, Wales and overseas. The Order of Women Freemasons also has lodges in Scotland. Neither body is recognized by the Grand Lodge of Scotland - inter-visitation is not permitted. | ||||
C |
---|
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:24 PM)Can anyone become a Freemason? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Yes – Freemasonry is open to people from all walks of life, regardless of their race, religion, sexual orientation or socio-economic position in society. To become a member under a 'regular' Grand Lodge, such as the Grand Lodge of Scotland, an applicant must however be male, and express a belief in a Supreme Being. | |||
D |
---|
Question: (Last edited: Tuesday, 13 April 2021, 7:56 PM)Does Freemasonry accept Roman Catholics? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: Yes. There are many Freemasons who are Roman Catholic. | ||||
H |
---|
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:27 PM)How many Degrees are there in Freemasonry? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Scottish Craft Freemasonry practises the following:
| |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:27 PM)How many Freemasons are there? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: There are around 30,000 freemasons operating under the Grand Lodge of Scotland, 25,000 under the Grand Lodge of Ireland, and around 200,000 under the United Grand Lodge of England. There are around six million freemasons in 'regular' Grand Lodges around the word. | |||
I |
---|
Question: (Last edited: Tuesday, 13 April 2021, 7:58 PM)If Masonry is so above-board, why is it “secret?” | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: There are fewer secrets to Freemasonry than most non-members imagine;
even many Masons are not entirely clear on what is and is not secret in
Masonry. The moral principles of Masonry are the same as those taught
you in Sunday school or at your mother’s knee (sometimes over it!); it
is only the exact procedures and words by which those principles are
taught in Masonry that are secret, for it is the knowledge of those that
distinguishes a Mason from those who are not members. To be entitled to
the fellowship peculiar to the Lodge, a Mason must be able to identify
himself, and these secrets provide the means for doing so. | |||
Question: (Last edited: Tuesday, 13 April 2021, 7:59 PM)Is Freemasonry a cult? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: That depends on what is meant by 'cult'. By some definitions,
Christianity, Islam, and Judaism are cults. By another definition,
golfing, bowling, and surfing the Internet are cults. But in the usual
use of the term, referring to a group that separates itself from society
and its members from their non-member friends, demands slavish
obedience from its adherents, engages in brainwashing techniques,
confiscates their resources, and sees itself in opposition to
established society, absolutely not! | |||
Question: (Last edited: Tuesday, 13 April 2021, 8:01 PM)Is Freemasonry a religion? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: No, Freemasonry is not a religion. Masons who treat it as such are mistaken. Freemasonry strongly encourages its members to belong to an established religion, although that is not a requirement for membership (only that a candidate profess a belief in a Supreme Being).
Masonry is a fraternal organization that encourages morality and
charity and studies philosophy. It has no clergy, no sacraments, and
does not promise salvation to its members. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:30 PM)Is Freemasonry an international order? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: Freemasonry exists throughout the world. However, each Grand Lodge is sovereign and independent. There is no international governing body for Freemasonry. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:30 PM)Is Freemasonry anti-Catholic? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: No. Masonry has no objection to the admission of a Catholic to the
Masonic fraternity. Whether the Roman Catholic Church objects to a
Catholic becoming a Freemason is their business, not ours. Masonry would
not counsel anyone to do something opposed by his religion.
The present position of the Church regarding Freemasonry is not
altogether clear; some sources indicate that the Vatican remains opposed
to any form of Freemasonry, others say that only those organizations
which “plot against the Church” (which Masonry does not) are proscribed,
and others see no problem. This is a matter for any individual Catholic
who might be interested in joining the Masons and his spiritual
advisor. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:32 PM)Is Masonry some kind of global conspiracy? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: The simplest answer is “no.” But that is not a very satisfying answer
for those who have heard many preposterous rumors about Masonry, the
“New World Order,” the Bavarian Illuminati, and so on. Let’s look at
some of the issues that have been raised: | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:33 PM)Is there a conflict between Freemasonry and established religion? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: There is nothing in Freemasonry that conflicts with most religions.
However, Freemasonry does insist on religious tolerance. To the extent
that certain religious groups would wish to suppress other religions or
persecute their followers, Freemasons would be in opposition to such
activities, and adherents of such groups would be both uncomfortable and
unwelcome in Masonry. It is also the case that certain religious groups are misinformed about Freemasonry and believe things about the Fraternity that are not true; basing their opinions on this false information, they then formulate opinions that create conflict. | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:33 PM)Is there no Masonic theology, then? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: An examination of the the degrees will reveal that there is a basic theology of Masonry, as follows: | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:34 PM)I’ve read the ritual in an exposé; what is all this strange stuff? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Remember that Masons solemnly pledge to keep the ritual secret. An
“exposé” is the product of someone who has broken a promise to his
friends and neighbour and to God. Can you really trust that such a
person is telling you the truth? | |||
M |
---|
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:35 PM)Masons say one thing, anti-Masons say another — whom should I believe? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: The history of Freemasonry is well documented, and its major players
include a vast number of contributors to society: men such as
Washington, Truman, and Churchill in politics, Goethe, Schiller, and
Conan Doyle in literature, Burl Ives, Ernest Borgnine, Gene Autry in the
performing arts, Mozart, Haydn, and Irving Berlin in music, and on and
on. Freemasons played essential roles in the civilization of
the New World, taming the west (Kit Carson was a Freemason), freeing
Latin America (Bolivar was a Mason, as was Bernardo O’Higgins), and so
on. Freemasons have established a vast array of charitable activities,
primarily focusing on the health field. The anti-Masons, when confronted with their own
contradictions, pile on ever more assumptions. Prove that “Lucifer” is
not mentioned in the Symbolic Rite of the first three degrees and they
will assert that it is the Scottish Rite that teaches “devil worship.”
Prove that there is no such thing in the 32 degrees, and they will claim
it is taught in the 33rd degree. A denial by a 33rd degree Mason will
lead to the attribution of Satanism to the Knights Templar. And so on.
The simpler hypothesis is that there is no such Satanic nonsense in
Freemasonry – given the conflict of assertions, Occam’s Razor directs us
to this choice.) The anti-Masons also engage in circular
reasoning: They claim that there is a great “Masonic conspiracy” to
control the world. Absent any evidence of that, they claim that the very
lack of evidence is “proof” of the power of the conspiracy. (Too many
Oliver Stone movies? Of course, even Congressmen have engaged in such
reasoning, as in the case of the “October surprise” investigation, when
Tom Foley suggested that the very lack of evidence was what justified a
Congressional hearing. An inability to reason against one’s own
prejudices is not unique to the anti-Masons.) | |||
W |
---|
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:35 PM)What about allegations that Freemasonry is Satanic or pagan? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Most of these are complete fabrications; the rest are
misunderstandings of the institution and its rituals. A number of
forgeries and alleged exposes of Masonry were created during the last
century. Most of the claims of “Satanism” in Masonry can be traced to
one or two of these fraudulent sources. Other such allegations are
simply made-up claims about what various Masonic emblems and symbols
stand for. Here are the facts: The term “Lucifer” as a name for the Devil or Satan, cannot be traced any farther back than the Middle Ages, and was only widely popularized by Milton’s epic poem, “Paradise Lost.” The Minnesota Masonic Manual (as one source on the lectures of Masonry) clearly identifies the Blazing Star as emblematic of the Star of Bethlehem, hardly a “Satanic” reference. It has nothing to do with the planet Venus. The Blazing Star is mentioned for about 30 seconds in a lecture some 20-30 minutes in length (it depends on jurisdiction) in the first degree of Masonry only, an amount of attention that could scarcely be described as “worship.” The “false dawn” is not heralded by Venus, but is a phenomenon produced by the Zodiacal Light, a band of dust lying in the plane of the Earth’s orbit, which most prominently appears as a skyglow before sunrise in the fall (the false dawn) and after sunset in the spring, but can only be observed under ideally dark conditions. In other words, the allegation about
Masonry in this case combines many errors: Taking a portion of a single
verse of the Bible out of context, misinterpreting its translation,
misunderstanding an astronomical term, misidentifying a Masonic emblem
with an astronomical object, and mis-characterizing the importance of a
symbol in the ritual. Perhaps all of this can be attributed to
ignorance, but since the facts are easy to obtain, one is forced to
wonder about how such allegations come to be and to persist. | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:36 PM)What about “blood oaths” and hideous penalties of the degrees? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: It is true that Masons must take solemn obligations to be faithful to the principles of Masonry, and their very nature and seriousness implies that there should be penalties. However, the language of these obligations makes it clear that the penalties are not actually inflicted by the Lodge or any body of Masonry but are expressions of how disgraced and contemptible one should feel for violating such an obligation. In some jurisdictions, the candidate is told that the penalties are of “ancient origin and symbolic only.” Later
degrees make this even more apparent, even if the actual information is
not specifically addressed to the candidate. But the true penalties for
violation of the laws of Masonry are three only: Admonition (or
reprimand), suspension, or expulsion. about Masons being maimed or murdered for violation of their oaths are just that: fiction. Not one single instance can be documented, despite the many attempts by the enemies of Masonry to promote this slander. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:36 PM)What are the benefits of becoming a Mason? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: There are numerous benefits to becoming a Mason, but they tend to be
personal and they are also quite varied: they can only be truly
discovered by becoming a member. But to try and give you an idea:
| ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:37 PM)What charities do Freemasons support? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: Whilst there are Masonic charities that cater specifically, but not
exclusively, for Masons or their dependants, Freemason lodges also make
significant donations to non-Masonic organizations. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:38 PM)What happens at Masonic Meetings? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Meetings, which like those of other groups, are open only to members, is normally in two parts. First, there are normal administrative procedures such as:
Second, there are the ceremonies for:
| |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:39 PM)What is Freemasonry’s relationship with politics? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: Freemasonry, as a body, will never express a view on politics or state
policy. The discussion of politics by members, in their capacity as a
freemason, has always been prohibited. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:39 PM)What is Freemasonry’s relationship with religion? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: All Freemasons are expected to have a belief in a Supreme Being,
Freemasonry does not seek to replace a Mason’s religion or provide a
substitute for it. It deals in a man’s relationship with his fellow man not in a man’s relationship with his God. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:40 PM)What is the role of various doctrinal books, like Pike’s Morals and Dogma? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Actually, there are no “doctrinal” books in Freemasonry. Freemasonry
is a society dedicated to free thinking and freedom of all kinds. No
Mason has the right to dictate to another what he shall or shall not
believe regarding his religion, his politics, or even his interpretation of the Masonic symbols. The preface also makes clear that no one is required to believe or accept any of the contents as truth. No “doctrinal” book would announce that every reader is “free to dissent” from any of its contents. Morals and Dogma was first of all written for those who have received the degrees of Scottish Rite Freemasonry in the form developed and edited by Albert Pike (the “Pike recension”). For someone to attempt to interpret the contents without the knowledge of the degrees is like trying to understand a book on quantum physics without having mastered the basics of dynamics and statics. Morals and Dogma was written under the authority of the Supreme Council, 33rd Degree, for the Southern Jurisdiction of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite of Freemasonry in the USA. The SJ of the USA, AASR, encompasses only a minority of Masons in the US and an even smaller proportion worldwide. Outside of the SJ of the US, Albert Pike is of much less influence than many non-Masons (and certainly anti-Masons) suppose. (The same is true of later works which also elucidate the degrees of the SJ of the US, such as Clausen’s Commentaries and Hutchens’ A Bridge to Light.) Similarly, anti-Masons like to quote (out of context, quite often) Manly Hall (who wrote many of his books before becoming a Freemason), Coil’s Masonic Encyclopedia, Albert Mackey, and others. Many of these men did their writing a century or more ago and use an idiom not well understood by those living today who are not familiar with such writing styles. These books are useful reference sources for those who seek to improve their knowledge of Masonry and who wish to sharpen their wits against the whetstone of great thinkers, but they are not doctrine. | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:40 PM)Why Can’t Christians Pray in Lodge? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Of course Christians can pray in Lodge! What they may not do is offer a
specifically Christian prayer as Lodge prayer, any more than a Jew or
Muslim may offer a prayer specific to his religion. | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:41 PM)Why do certain fundamentalist groups oppose Freemasonry? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Mostly out of ignorance and misinformation, although possibly out of
fear of competition for time and attention with the church (churches
have been suffering the same loss of active membership over the past few
decades as has Freemasonry). Ignorance of Masonry allows misinformation
to spread. For example, it is claimed that Freemasonry has a “plan of
salvation” that is in opposition to that of the Christian Church. Simply not true; nothing in any of the Masonic degrees refers to salvation. | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:41 PM)Why do Freemasons take Obligations / Oaths? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: New members make solemn promises concerning their behaviour both in the
Lodge and in society. Members also promise to keep confidential the way
they recognize each other when visiting another Lodge. Freemasons also
commit to support others in time of need but only so far as it does not
conflict with their family and public obligations. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:42 PM)Why do Masons insult non-Masons as being 'profane'? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Again, this is a misunderstanding over the use of archaic language. The
word “profane” comes from two Latin words, “pro,” meaning “before,” and
“fanum,” meaning “temple.” In earlier usage, “profane” had a more
literal meaning of “outside the temple.” It was simply an antonym for
the term “sacred,” just as “secular” still is. (Classical music lovers
will note, for example, the Debussy work, “Danses sacrees et profanes,”
as a use of the same word in French with this meaning.) | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:43 PM)Why do Masons want to hoodwink people? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: This is a misunderstanding arising from the use of archaic language in
Masonry when modern meanings are different from what they were a couple
of centuries ago. (E.g., “let” used to mean “hinder”–which it still does
in tennis, but for most usages, it means the exact opposite: to allow
or permit.) | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:43 PM)Why do some churches not like Freemasonry? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: There are elements within churches who misunderstand Freemasonry and
its objectives. They confuse secular rituals with religious liturgy. There are many Masons in churches where their leaders have been openly critical of the organization. Masonry has always actively encouraged its members to be active in their own religion. | |||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:44 PM)Why do you wear regalia? | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Answer: Wearing regalia is historic and symbolic. Like a uniform, the regalia indicates the rank of the wearer in the organisation. | ||||
Question: (Last edited: Sunday, 20 December 2020, 2:44 PM)Why is there so much interest in Masonry today? | |||
---|---|---|---|
Answer: Over the last four centuries, Freemasonry seems to have flourished
during times of great enlightenment and change. It is no coincidence
that Freemasonry rose to prominence during the Age of Enlightenment -
where a new generation believed it could discover ways to gain personal
improvement, bring order to society, and understand the whole universe.
This statement is perhaps even stronger today than it was in the 18th
century. | |||